Ingredient Substitutions: Exact Ratios and What Changes

Missing an ingredient? Exact swap ratios for buttermilk, self-raising flour, eggs, cream, wine, herbs and grains, plus what changes and when not to substitute.

By AromaPlata editorial · Published · How we write and check content

10 min read

Running out of one ingredient halfway through a recipe doesn't have to mean a trip to the shop or a meal that never gets made. Most everyday ingredients have a stand-in already in your cupboard, as long as you know the ratio and what it will change.

The ratios below come from university extension services. For each swap you'll find what will be different — rise, texture, colour or flavour — and the situations where substituting is a bad idea.

The short answer

  • Make buttermilk by putting 1 tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar in a jug and topping it up to 240 ml (1 cup) with milk.
  • Never swap bicarbonate of soda and baking powder spoon for spoon: 1 teaspoon of baking powder equals ¼ teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda plus ½ teaspoon of cream of tartar.
  • Use 1 teaspoon of dried herbs in place of 1 tablespoon of chopped fresh herbs, a 3:1 ratio.
  • Egg substitutes work for up to three eggs in moist bakes; cakes that rely on eggs for lift, such as sponges, rarely survive the swap.
  • Never change the type or amount of acid in a pickling or canning recipe; there, acidity is a safety control, not a matter of taste.

Before you swap: cooking versus baking

In soups, stews and sauces you can substitute fairly freely and correct by tasting. Baking is less forgiving: flour, fat, sugar, eggs and raising agents each do a structural job, so a swap that changes the liquid, acid or protein changes the result.

North Dakota State University (NDSU) Extension describes substitutes as giving a product that is similar to the original, not identical, and suggests keeping them for unexpected situations. A substitute rescues a recipe; it doesn't improve it.

Baking: buttermilk, self-raising flour and raising agents

Baking substitutions and what they change
MissingUse insteadWhat changes
Buttermilk, 240 ml (1 cup)1 tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar, topped up to 240 ml (1 cup) with milk; stir and leave a few minutes until slightly thickened. Or 240 ml (1 cup) plain yoghurt.Thinner and a little less tangy than real buttermilk, but it supplies the acid that recipes with bicarbonate of soda need. Fine for scones, pancakes, soda bread and cakes.
Self-raising flour (self-rising), 125 g (1 cup)120 g (1 cup minus 2 tsp) plain flour (all-purpose) + 1½ tsp baking powder + ½ tsp saltRises much like the bought version. US self-rising flour contains salt; UK self-raising is usually unsalted, so skip the salt if your recipe adds its own.
Baking powder, 1 tsp¼ tsp bicarbonate of soda (baking soda) + ½ tsp cream of tartarWorks well, but this mix starts reacting as soon as it gets wet, so get the tin into the oven promptly.

Why bicarbonate of soda and baking powder are not interchangeable

Illinois Extension is blunt about it: the two are not interchangeable. Bicarbonate of soda is an alkali and only produces gas when it meets an acid in the recipe, such as buttermilk, yoghurt, lemon juice, vinegar or brown sugar. Baking powder already contains its own acid (cream of tartar) plus a little starch.

Bicarbonate is also far stronger: the swap above uses ¼ teaspoon to do the work of a full teaspoon of baking powder. Used one-for-one, there won't be enough acid to neutralise it, and Illinois Extension notes that too much bicarbonate without enough acid can leave a metallic taste. Going the other way, it suggests trying three times as much baking powder in place of bicarbonate; treat that as a rescue, not a reliable swap.

Replacing eggs in baking

First work out what the egg is doing. In muffins and quick breads it mostly binds and adds moisture, which is easy to replace. In sponges and meringues it traps air and sets the structure, which is not. N.C. Cooperative Extension gives these ratios for each large egg:

  • Ground flaxseed: 1 tbsp ground flaxseed mixed with 3 tbsp water, left until it gels. Binds well in cookies, muffins and pancakes, but adds a nutty flavour, flecks and a denser crumb. It doesn't suit brownies or creamy desserts such as pumpkin pie.
  • Mashed banana: 60 ml (¼ cup) mashed ripe banana, about half a medium banana. Adds moisture and sweetness, and you will taste it; best in banana bread, muffins and pancakes.
  • Unsweetened apple sauce: 60 ml (¼ cup). Moisture and a little sweetness, with less flavour than banana.
  • Soft tofu, puréed: 60 ml (¼ cup). The better choice for quiches and custard-style fillings.

Fruit purées make bakes denser; an extra ½ teaspoon of baking powder can lighten them.

When egg substitutes fail

  • Recipes with more than three eggs. Substitutes generally fail; find a recipe with fewer eggs.
  • Pound cakes, sponges and angel food cakes. The eggs are the structure and the lift.
  • Dishes where the egg is the point, such as omelettes and scrambles, which powdered egg replacers can't make.

Sugars and syrups

Sugar and syrup substitutions
MissingUse insteadWhat changes
Brown sugar, 220 g (1 cup, packed)200 g (1 cup) granulated sugar + 60 ml (¼ cup) molasses or black treacle; or granulated sugar aloneThe molasses gives back colour, moisture and a caramel flavour; use less of it for a light brown sugar. Granulated sugar alone gives paler, crisper results.
Sugar, 200 g (1 cup), in baking240 ml (1 cup) honey; cut the recipe's other liquid by 60 ml (¼ cup), add ½ tsp bicarbonate of soda per 240 ml honey, and lower the oven by about 15 °C (25 °F)Darker crust, moister crumb, honey flavour. NDSU suggests replacing only half the sugar in cakes, cookies and brownies, and mixing the honey into the fat or liquid first to avoid a soggy top layer.
Sugar, 200 g (1 cup)180 ml (¾ cup) maple syrup; cut the recipe's other liquid by 45 ml (3 tbsp)A clear maple flavour and a softer texture.
Golden syrup, honey or maple syrup, in glazes, dressings and drizzlesAny of the others, spoon for spoonMainly a change of flavour; maple syrup is thinner. Where the syrup sets the texture, as in flapjacks, the result may be softer or more crumbly.

Cream, soured cream, yoghurt and crème fraîche

Dairy substitutions for cooking and baking
MissingUse insteadWhat changes
Double cream (heavy cream), 240 ml (1 cup), for cooking or baking180 ml (¾ cup) milk + 75 g (⅓ cup) melted butterIt won't whip: cooking and baking only. In sauces, add it towards the end and keep it at a gentle simmer.
Soured cream (sour cream), 240 ml (1 cup)240 ml (1 cup) plain yoghurt; if it will be heated, stir in 1 tbsp cornflour (cornstarch) firstTangier and a little thinner. NDSU recommends the cornflour to stop yoghurt separating in cooked dishes.

In cold dips, dressings and toppings, crème fraîche, soured cream and thick yoghurt swap spoon for spoon; yoghurt is the sharpest and least rich. In hot sauces, full-fat crème fraîche and double cream are generally more forgiving of heat, while yoghurt and soured cream are better stirred in off the heat or stabilised with cornflour.

Savoury swaps: wine, stock, herbs, alliums and acidity

Savoury substitutions and what they change
MissingUse insteadWhat changes
Wine, 120 ml (½ cup), in a sauce, stew or risotto120 ml (½ cup) stock + 1 tsp wine vinegar or lemon juice; in pan sauces and soups, add the acid near the endLess depth, but the acid restores the wine's lift; use red wine vinegar for red wine. NDSU's alternative for 240 ml (1 cup) wine: 13 tbsp water, 3 tbsp lemon juice, 1 tbsp sugar.
Stock, 240 ml (1 cup)1 stock cube or 1 tsp stock powder dissolved in 240 ml (1 cup) boiling water; or water simmered with onion, carrot, celery, herb stalks and saltCubes and powders are salty, so season at the end. A quick homemade stock is lighter in flavour.
Fresh herbs, 1 tbsp chopped1 tsp dried herbs (or ½ tsp ground)Fine in anything cooked for a while; add dried herbs early so they soften. They can't replace fresh herbs as a raw garnish.
Garlic, 1 small clove⅛ tsp garlic powder or ¼ tsp dried minced garlicFlatter and less pungent. Stir powder into sauces, marinades and rubs rather than frying it on its own.
Onion, 1 small (about ¼ cup chopped)1 tsp onion powder or 1–2 tbsp dried minced onionNo texture or browned sweetness; best in soups, sauces, meatballs and dressings.
Lemon juice, 1 tsp, for flavour½ tsp vinegarVinegar tastes sharper, so use half. It has no citrus aroma; add a little grated zest if you have any.
Dry breadcrumbs, for coating or bindingFinely crushed crackers, or rolled oats pulsed brieflyCrackers are saltier, so cut back the salt. Oats soak up more liquid and have no fixed ratio; add a spoonful at a time until the mixture holds.

Stale bread makes better crumbs than either swap; see what to do with stale bread. For stock that costs nothing, save peelings for vegetable scrap stock.

Swapping rice and other grains

Most grains can stand in for each other in salads, side dishes, soups and stuffed vegetables, but the liquid and cooking time change a lot. The figures below are from Oregon State University Extension's Food Hero programme and are by volume, so measure the grain and liquid with the same cup or jug.

Liquid and cooking time for 1 part dry grain
GrainLiquidHow to cookGood swap for
Brown rice2¼ partsSimmer covered 35–40 minutes, then stand covered 5–10 minutesWhite rice in pilafs and bowls; chewier and nuttier
Quinoa2 partsSimmer covered 12 minutes, then stand 5–10 minutesRice or couscous in salads and bowls
Bulgur wheat2 partsSimmer covered 12 minutesRice in pilafs; couscous in salads
Whole-wheat couscous2 parts, boilingStir in, cover, off the heat for 10 minutesThe quickest swap for rice
Millet2 partsSimmer covered 20 minutesRice or quinoa
Hulled barley3 partsSimmer covered 45–60 minutesRice in soups and stews
FarroPlenty, like pasta (about 8 parts)Boil uncovered 30–40 minutes, then drainBarley or rice in soups and grain salads
  • Slow grain, quick recipe: if you swap brown rice or barley into a dish written for white rice, cook the grain separately first and add it near the end.
  • Creamy dishes: risotto and rice pudding depend on starchy short-grain rice; other grains won't turn creamy.
  • Leftovers: cooked rice needs cooling quickly and eating promptly; see the cooked rice safety guide. Working from the cupboard rather than a recipe? The AromaPlata kitchen tool suggests dishes for what you have.

Common questions

Can I just use plain milk instead of buttermilk?

Only if the recipe uses baking powder alone. If it uses bicarbonate of soda, the buttermilk's acid is what makes the bicarbonate work; with plain milk the bake rises less and, as Illinois Extension notes, too much bicarbonate without enough acid can taste metallic. Adding lemon juice or vinegar to the milk fixes this.

I have bicarbonate of soda but no cream of tartar. Can I still replace baking powder?

Yes. NDSU Extension lists ¼ teaspoon of bicarbonate of soda plus 120 ml (½ cup) of buttermilk, soured milk or yoghurt in place of 1 teaspoon of baking powder. Use 120 ml less of the recipe's other liquid so the batter isn't too wet.

Can I thicken a sauce with plain flour instead of cornflour?

Yes. NDSU Extension gives 2 tablespoons of plain flour for every 1 tablespoon of cornflour. Simmer the sauce for a few minutes after adding it to cook out the raw flour taste, and expect a slightly cloudier, less glossy finish.

How do I replace cake flour in an American recipe?

NDSU Extension's swap for 1 cup of sifted cake flour is 1 cup minus 2 tablespoons of sifted plain flour. The cake will be slightly less tender, because plain flour has more protein than cake flour.

Sources

The times, temperatures and rules above come from these sources. Where they disagree, the guide says so.

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Email us at hello@aromaplata.com.