Past its best or unsafe? How to tell
Fruit and vegetables age in two different ways. Losing water makes them limp, bendy or wrinkled; ripening makes them soft and sweet. Neither is a safety problem on its own. Rot is different: mould, slime, leaking liquid and collapse mean microbes are breaking the food down.
- Limp, bendy or wrinkled (celery, carrots, peppers, lettuce, herbs): water loss. Revive it in cold water or cook it.
- Soft and very ripe (tomatoes, bananas, stone fruit): cook, bake, blend or freeze it.
- Bruised or with a small damaged patch: the FDA advises cutting away damaged or bruised areas before you prepare or eat the produce.
- Slimy, leaking or smelling rotten: this is decay, not age. Compost the affected leaves or pieces, and the whole item if it has spread.
Prepared salad in bags is the exception to all of this. It carries a use-by date, which is about safety rather than quality, so crisping it up in water doesn't extend it. See use-by vs best-before for how the two labels differ.
Mould: firm produce versus soft produce
The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service draws a clear line based on how dense and wet the produce is:
- Firm, low-moisture produce such as cabbage, peppers and carrots: you can use it. Cut off at least 2.5 cm (1 in) around and below the mould spot, keeping the knife out of the mould itself so you don't spread it. Mould struggles to get into dense foods.
- Soft, high-moisture produce such as cucumbers, peaches and tomatoes: throw it away. It can be contaminated below the surface, where you can't see it.
- Anything covered in mould: throw it away, whatever it is.
Reviving limp greens, herbs, celery and carrots
Limp vegetables have lost water, and cold water can put some of it back. It works best on produce that is bendy but still dry and whole.
- Trim. Cut a thin slice off the base of celery sticks, carrots, a lettuce stem or herb stalks, so they have a fresh surface to draw water through.
- Soak. Love Food Hate Waste suggests 10–15 minutes in an ice-cold water bath for wilted lettuce, and at least 30 minutes in a bowl of cold water for celery and carrots. Do longer soaks in the fridge.
- Dry and chill. Drain, pat dry, wrap loosely in a clean tea towel and refrigerate. Use them soon, before they wilt again.
For soft herbs such as parsley, coriander and mint, trim the stalks and stand the bunch upright in a jar of water like flowers, loosely covered with a bag, in the fridge.
Water won't fix leaves that are yellow, see-through or slimy, or carrots that have gone soft and wet. Pick those out. Anything that is merely still floppy after a soak is fine to cook: wilt greens into garlicky greens pasta or simmer the lot into an any-vegetable soup.
Soft tomatoes, wrinkly peppers and overripe bananas
- Soft or wrinkled tomatoes have lost the texture you want in a salad but are ideal for cooking, where they break down into a sauce. Cut out any bruised patch and cook them into a quick tomato sauce, a soup or shakshuka. A sauce freezes well in portions. A tomato with any mould on it goes in the compost, because tomatoes count as soft produce.
- Wrinkly peppers have lost water, but the flesh underneath is fine for cooking. Halve and deseed them, then roast them in a hot oven until the skins blister and blacken in patches. Put them in a covered bowl for a few minutes and the skins slip off. Blend them into soup or sauce, or stir them through pasta. Peppers are firm produce, so a small mould spot can be cut out, with 2.5 cm (1 in) to spare.
- Overripe bananas with heavily speckled or black skins are at their sweetest for baking; check the flesh for mould, not the skin for colour. Use them in overripe banana bread or pancakes, or as an egg replacer in baking (the ingredient substitutions guide has the ratio).
Herb stems, vegetable scraps and citrus
- Soft herb stalks (parsley, coriander, basil, mint) are just as tasty as the leaves. Chop them finely with the leaves, or blend them into herb-stem salsa verde, pesto or a dressing. Woody stems from rosemary and thyme are too tough to eat, but you can drop them whole into a stock or stew and fish them out before serving.
- Vegetable scraps make free stock. Keep a bag in the freezer for onion ends and skins, carrot peelings, celery tops and leaves, leek greens, mushroom stalks and herb stalks, and when it's full make vegetable scrap stock. Only clean, sound scraps belong in it: if you wouldn't eat it, don't simmer it. Rinse vegetables before peeling them; the FDA advises rinsing produce before you peel it so dirt isn't carried from the knife onto the food. Go easy on cabbage and broccoli trimmings, which can dominate the flavour.
- Citrus: grate the zest before you squeeze the juice, because zesting a squeezed half is almost impossible. Freeze the zest in a small tub, and freeze the juice in an ice-cube tray, measuring 1 tablespoon into each compartment so you know what every cube holds. A lemon or orange with mould on its peel goes in the compost.
Sprouting potatoes, onions and garlic
Potatoes need more care than other tired produce. Iowa State University Extension explains that potatoes contain natural compounds called glycoalkaloids, mainly solanine and chaconine. Light makes potatoes produce chlorophyll, which turns them green, and triggers more solanine in the skin. The compounds are most concentrated in sprouts, green skin and the area around the eyes. High levels can cause headaches, vomiting and other digestive problems, and cooking does not destroy them.
- Firm potato, small sprouts, green only skin-deep: cut out each sprout including the eye, and peel and cut away every green-tinged area generously. The rest can be cooked.
- Throw it away if the green goes beneath the skin into the flesh, if the potato is soft or shrivelled, if the sprouts are 2.5 cm (1 in) or longer, or if a cooked potato tastes bitter. Iowa State's own cut-off is long sprouts on a shrivelled potato; discarding at either sign is the more cautious rule.
Garlic: Utah State University Extension says a green shoot inside a clove usually means the garlic is older; it is still okay to eat but will taste bitter. Halve the clove and lift the shoot out with the tip of a knife. Throw away cloves that are soft, shrivelled or mouldy.
Onions: treat a sprouting onion as a use-today onion. If the bulb is still firm, with no mould and no soft, wet or dark patches, cut out the green core and cook the rest. If it has gone soft, hollow or mouldy, compost it.
Rescue, use today or compost: a quick reference
| Produce | Rescue it | Use it today | Compost it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lettuce and salad leaves | Limp: 10–15 minutes in iced water | Wilted but dry: shred into soup or a stir-fry | Slimy, see-through or mouldy leaves; bagged salad past its use-by date |
| Celery and carrots | Bendy: trim, then at least 30 minutes in cold water | Rubbery: soup, stock or a stew base | Slimy, or soft and wet; mould beyond a small spot |
| Soft herbs | Trim and stand in a jar of water in the fridge | Wilted: salsa verde, pesto or soup | Black, slimy or mouldy |
| Tomatoes | Not needed | Soft or wrinkled: sauce, soup or shakshuka | Any mould; leaking or collapsing |
| Peppers | Not needed | Wrinkly: roast, then soup or sauce | Soft and wet; mould beyond a small spot (cut 2.5 cm around small spots) |
| Bananas | Freeze, peeled, before the flesh turns | Speckled to black: banana bread or pancakes | Mould on the flesh |
| Potatoes | Not possible | Firm with small sprouts: remove sprouts and green parts, then cook | Green beneath the skin; soft or shrivelled; sprouts 2.5 cm (1 in) or longer; bitter |
| Onions and garlic | Not possible | Sprouting but firm: remove the shoot and cook | Soft, shrivelled or mouldy |
| Lemons, limes and oranges | Not needed | Softening: zest, juice and freeze | Mould on the peel |
Once you've rescued what you can, the AromaPlata kitchen tool suggests recipes for the ingredients you have, and the fridge clear-out formulas turn odds and ends into a meal.